Friday, March 8, 2013

Violence Against Women Act and Its Impact on Immigrant Women


On February 28, 2013, Congress passed the bill to renew the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA). VAWA is the federal law providing legal protection and services to protect women, and some men from domestic and sexual violence. Prior to the enactment of VAWA in 1994, there were no legal protections for domestic violence victims. Women were treated as property of men and courts often mishandled the domestic violence cases. It was not until the 1970s that the United States began to recognize domestic violence as a significant social problem. By the late 1970s, a number of shelters for batter women were built nationwide. Finally, in 1994, under the leadership of Vice President Joseph Biden (at the time a U.S. Senator D-Del.), Congress passed VAWA. Since then, VAWA has been renewed twice without controversy in 2000 and again in 2005. VAWA has made substantial progress in addressing domestic violence issues. It created a shift in the perception of domestic violence in the United States.[1]It has “improved the criminal justice response to violence against women” and has “ensured that victims and their families have access to the services.”[2]Despite the progress 1994 VAWA has made, domestic violence has remained a serious societal problem and many scholars called for stronger protection to target multiple areas in need of improvement.

The renewed bill authorized $659 million over five years for various programs that help prevent domestic violence and extend protections for victims with diverse backgrounds such as gays and lesbians, immigrants and Native American women. The 1994 VAWA expired in October 2011 but Congress failed to reauthorize it due to objections from Republicans over the new provisions in the bill.One of the bill’s most hotly debated provisions was adding undocumented immigrants to the list of women who can apply for law enforcement certifications for U nonimmigrant status, also known as U visas. The U visa is a temporary visa that “can be sought by victims of certain crimes who are currently assisting or have previously assisted law enforcement in the investigation or prosecution of a crime, or who are likely to be helpful in the investigation or prosecution of criminal activity.”[3] While U-visas are not exclusively for domestic violence victims, they allow undocumented immigrants to obtain legal status to stay in the US if they can assist the police to prosecute their abusers. This part of the proposal has drawn opposition from Republicans who argued that this provision would create potentials for fraud and abuse of visas from people who try to obtain permanent status in the US when they would not otherwise qualify.[4]  Earlier proposals included the increase in the number of U visas available, but eventually this provision was taken out. Currently, there are only 10,000 U visas available each year.[5]

Besides the a number of issues that victims of domestic violence face such as protecting children from abuse, finding and securing emergency shelter, informing family of the situation, and sorting through housing and financial options for the future, immigrant women have to deal with additional issues. Immigrant women face language barriers, economic insecurity, and discrimination due to gender, race or ethnicity.[6]Most importantly, abusers often use their partners’ immigration status as a tool of control. The problems of domestic violence are "terribly exacerbated in marriages where one spouse is not a citizen and the non-citizen's legal status depends on his or her marriage to the abuser" because “the immigrant victim ability to obtain or maintain lawful immigration status may depend on her relationship to her United States citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse and his willingness to file an immigrant relative petition on her behalf.”[7] In such situations, abusers often force immigrant partners to remain in the relationship by exerting control over the partner’s immigration status.[8]

Due to their status, immigrant women are less likely to report abuse to authorities. However, VAWA allows immigrant victims of domestic violence who are married to U.S. citizens or residents, to self-petition for legal status in the United States without relying on their abusive spouses to sponsor the petition.[9]The USCIS website includes the list of the requirements for U-visas. If immigrant women entered into the marriage in good faith, they can apply for U-visas but they must prove: 1) they have been abused in the United States by a U.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse, or have been abused by a U.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse abroad while the spouse was employed by the U.S. government or a member of the U.S. uniformed services, or they are the parent of a child who has been subjected to abuse by a U.S. citizen or permanent spouse and 2) they have resided with the spouse and 3) they are a person of good moral character.[10]Once a self-petition has been approved, the immigrant victim can then apply for a permanent residence status.[11]Since undocumented women are more likely to fear to be reported of their illegal status, the new VAWA would be of great help to the ones who probably need it the most.

However, as mentioned above, there are still many other obstacles for battered immigrants to report the abuse, including language barriers. Many non-profit organizations are dedicated to assist domestic violence victims by providing translated legal services and confidential shelter for them and their children. In the Washington, D.C. area alone there are numerous organizations such as Ayuda, My Sister’s Place, the Asian Pacific American Legal Resource Center (APALRC), Asian / Pacific-Islander Domestic Violence Resource Project (DVRP), the Hartley House, House of Ruth and many more. Further, the increasing and high number of immigrant victims of domestic violence suggests that the number of U-Visas currently available for them fails to fully provide protections that they need. Although the 2013 VAWA may provide stronger protections than the 1994 VAWA, there is still room for improvements.

Min Ji Ku
Blogger, Criminal Law Brief

Image by: NCAI


[1] http://thescholarlawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/Haugen2.pdf
[2] Id.
[3] http://www.dhs.gov/u-visa-law-enforcement-certification-resource-guide
[4] http://www.ibtimes.com/violence-against-women-act-protections-immigrants-fuel-political-fight-426176
[5] http://www.hrw.org/news/2013/02/28/us-violence-against-women-act-renewed
[6] http://www.wcl.american.edu/journal/genderlaw/10/10-1orloff.pdf
Gender Soc. Pol'y & L. 95
[7] Id.
[8] http://www.futureswithoutviolence.org/userfiles/file/Children_and_Families/Immigrant.pdf
[9] http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/uscis/menuitem.eb1d4c2a3e5b9ac89243c6a7543f6d1a/?vgnextoid=b85c3e4d77d73210VgnVCM100000082ca60aRCRD&vgnextchannel=b85c3e4d77d73210VgnVCM100000082ca60aRCRD
[10] Id
[11] Id.

Monday, March 4, 2013

Should United States v. Jones Affect Law Enforcement’s Use of Automatic License Plate Recognition Readers?


In United States v. Jones,[1]the United States Supreme Court held that the physical attachment of a Global Positioning System[2](GPS) tracking device on a vehicle constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment[3]of the United States Constitution.  This decision has left law enforcement questioning the policies and procedures they can employ when utilizing technology to track and store information on individuals suspected of criminal conduct.  The reality is that technology is constantly changing.  Law enforcement needs to be able to change and adapt to the technology in order to use the technology to enhance the investigation of criminal activity.

The Automatic License Plate Recognition reader, more commonly referred to as an ALPR, has quickly become a common tool utilized by law enforcement throughout many police departments.[4]  The ALPR uses digital cameras mounted on a law enforcement vehicle or at stationary locations to snap images of passing license plates.[5]  As a vehicle approaches, the ALPR takes a series of photographs and stores them in a digital file.  The most advanced can photograph up to 1,800 license plates per minute at a speed of up to 140 miles per hour.  These digital photographs are transmitted to a computer system inside of the vehicle and optical character recognition software converts the plate numbers in the photographs into text.  Once converted, the ALPR system compares the plate numbers to available databases, often called hotlists, including lists of stolen automobiles, active arrest warrants, suspended licenses and registrations, and AMBER alerts.  This is a valuable tool for law enforcement as it essentially observes and compares information faster than an officer would be able to do and then notifies the officer when a license plate matches something on a hotlist.
                 
Some departments are using the ALPR not just for this observational comparison, but also for data collection.  Meaning they not only alert an officer as to whether a license plate has hit on a hotlist, but it also tracks the time and date of every license plate it reads.  This information is placed in a searchable database whether or not any evidence of wrong doing was found and the information can be stored indefinitely. [6]
                 
It is not difficult for law enforcement to easily determine the likely driver of a given car by cross-referencing a license plate number with state motor vehicle records.  With enough ALPR systems installed in a community, law enforcement could theoretically create an accurate and pervasive record of a person’s movements over months or years.  This of course can be very helpful for law enforcement in cases of child abduction for example.  Essentially, after the report of a child abduction, law enforcement can pull all registered license plate owners in the area of the abduction at the time it occurred.     

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) however, has expressed concerns about police departments that are gathering and storing information about the travel patterns of all vehicles, regardless of whether they are vehicles of interest.[7]  The fear from a privacy standpoint is that once it is effectively deployed nationwide, it can be used as a kind of mass, warrantless tracking system.[8]Such concerns prompted state Rep. Todd Rutherford, D-Columbia to propose a bill in the South Carolina House that would ban the technology in the state.[9]“There is nothing to protect [the data],” Rutherford  said “All they are doing is collecting it.”[10]According to the ACLU, there are currently only two states, Maine and New Hampshire, with “positive laws” governing how the technology can be used.  New Hampshire bans them, and Maine requires data to be deleted after twenty-one days unless it is part of an investigation.[11] The ACLU says “responsible deletion of data is the exception, not the norm.” [12]
                 
In light of the Jones decision, the ALPR will not likely mandate any type of judicial review.  The ALPR is not a device that is placed on any individual’s vehicle for the purposes of tracking the person.  The ALPR is installed on law enforcements’ vehicles and it indiscriminately reads license plates and compares them to databases which contain hotlists of wanted suspects and traffic offenses listed to their registration or license.  The Court determined in Jones, that a search now occurs both when there is a state-law trespass on property and when the government infringes upon a reasonable expectation of privacy.[13]  The Court explained that “Katz did not narrow the Fourth Amendment’s scope.”[14]  The Court further opined Katz, “established that ‘property rights are not the sole measure of Fourth Amendment violations,’ but did not ‘snuf[f] out the previously recognized protection for property.”[15]
                 
Additionally the Court has set precedent that people have no reasonable expectation of privacy in public spaces, because “the police cannot reasonably be expected to avert their eyes from evidence of criminal activity that could have been observed by any member of the public.”[16]  Further, in Knotts, the Court concluded that “a person traveling in an automobile on public thoroughfares has no reasonable expectation of privacy in his movements from one place to another.”[17]  Finally, the ALPR does not give police any extrasensory ability or intrude in the home as the Court found to be the troubling factor in Kyllo.[18]

The data compilation kept by law enforcement likely will not be considered a Fourth Amendment violation either.  The Court in Smith v. Maryland[19], held that warrantless access to pen registers raises no Fourth Amendment concerns.  The court reasoned that a person ought to understand that her phone company may collect a record of all the phone numbers she dials.  The Court further rationalized that a person voluntarily turns over this information to the phone company and should reasonably expect this information to be possibly conveyed to others.  Thus a person traveling in a community that utilizes ALPR should reasonably expect that their license plates may be read by advanced technologies and recorded into a database.  The truth is that most ALPR’s are not only utilized by law enforcement but  are used also as a method of electronic toll collection on pay-per-use roads and cataloging the movements of traffic or individuals like E-ZPass.[20]  Law enforcement can easily subpoena information on registration plates captured by these entities as well.   Justice Sotomayor, in Jones, did caution in her concurring opinion that this third party issue may need to be accessed again when pertaining to information given over by an individual to third parties, however until it is, law enforcement should be safe to track suspects of criminal activity through the use of an ALPR reader.

Diana Cobo
Junior Blog Editor,  Criminal Law Brief

Image by: Whirling Phoenix



[1] See United States v. Jones, 132 S. Ct. 945 (2012).  Available at http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6122276400056758151&q=united+states+v.+antoine+jones&hl=en&as_sdt=2,21&as_vis=1
[2] U.S. Air Force Fact Sheet: Global Positioning Systems Directorate, L.A. Air Force Base (Jan. 7, 2011),  available at http://www.losangeles.af.mil/library/factsheets/factsheet.asp?id=5311.
[3] U.S. Const. amend. IV.
[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recognition
[5] Stephen Rushin, The Judicial Response To Mass Police Surveillance, 2011 U. Ill. J.L. Tech. and Pol’y 281, 285 (2011).
[6] ACLU, Automatic License Plate Readers:  Are You Being Followed? Available at http://www.aclu.org/maps/automatic-license-plate-readers-are-you-being-followed
[7] Rebecca DiLeonardo, ACLU requests information on automatic license plate readers, Jurist; available at http://jurist.org/paperchase/2012/07/aclu-requests-information-on-automatic-license-plate-readers
[8]Ryan Gallagher, Police Across U.S. Quietly Turning to Cameras That Track All Vehicles’ Movements:  Survey available at http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2013/01/14/automatic_license_plate_readers_survey_shows_most_u_s_police_agencies_plan.html
[9] Christopher McKagen, Columbia Representative’s Bill Would Ban Johnsonville’s Use Of License Plate Readers, available at http://www.scnow.com/observer/news/article_3eee84c8-5aa1-11e2-888f-0019bb30f31a.html
[10] Id.
[11] Julia Angwin and Jennifer Valentino-Devries, New Tracking Frontier:  Your License Plates, available at http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390443995604578004723603576296.html
[12] ACLU, Automatic License Plate Readers: A Threat To American’s Privacy, available at http://www.aclu.org/automatic-license-plate-readers-threat-americans-privacy
[13] See Jones, 132 S. Ct. at 950 (citing Katz, 389 U.S. 347, 347 (1967)).
[14] See Jones, 132 S. Ct. at 951.
[15] Id (quoting Soldal v. Cook County, 506 U.S. 56, 60 (1992)).
[16] See California v. Greenwood, 486 U.S. 35, 43-44 (1988).  Available at http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/California_v._Greenwood
[17] See United States v. Knotts, 460 U.S. 276, 281 (1983). Available at http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=460&invol=276
[18]See Kyllo v. United States, 533 U.S. 27 , 36 (2001).  Available at http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=15840045591115721227&q=kyllo+v.+united+states&hl=en&as_sdt=2,21&as_vis=1
[19] See Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735, 742 (1979).  Available at http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?navby=CASE&court=US&vol=442&page=735
[20] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recognition

Friday, March 1, 2013

Roughing the Partner: Athletes and Violence Against Women

It is estimated that nearly twenty-five percent of all women will be victims of domestic violence during their life.  Domestic Violence is defined as “the willful intimidation, physical assault, battery, sexual assault, and/or other abusive behavior perpetrated by an intimate partner against another.”[1] While domestic violence impacts all types of couples, relationships involving professional athletes appear to have increased rates of domestic violence.  According to the National Coalition Against Violent Athletes, in the late 1990’s, 8.5% of the general population was charged with assault, while the number was nearly 36.8% for athletes.[2] We hear of these cases all the time in the news.  In late 2012, Jovan Belcher, an NFL player for the Kansas City Chiefs, committed suicide after he shot and killed Kasandra Perkins, his girlfriend and mother of his infant daughter.[3]  Brandon Marshall, a wide receiver for the Denver Broncos has been involved in several domestic violence incidents––police have been called to his home on at least eight separate occasions for domestic violence.[4] Marshall has also been charged with assaulting a woman at a nightclub in New York.  Manny Ramirez, once one of the Major League Baseball’s stars, was arrested for battery after hitting his wife.[5]  These are just a few examples of hundreds.
 A 2010 survey performed by Jeff Benedict, a professor who specifically studies athletes and crime, found that in the first six months of 2010, twenty percent of all professional and college athlete arrests were for violence against women.[6]  Why do athletes engage in domestic violence more than the general public?  Many assert that the reason is that they are not held accountable by the leagues or by the criminal justice system.

There are calls for the professional leagues to do more regarding professional and college athlete domestic violence.  Because these would be civil remedies since the leagues cannot create criminal punishments or sanctions, I won’t go into them in detail.  However, the main arguments are that players who are convicted, or even just arrested for domestic violence, should face punishment from employers such as suspensions or docked pay.  There are problems with this theory however.  In most cases, members of the general population are not punished for acts that occur when they are not working.  What makes professional athletes different?  Some would argue that playing sports is not the type of employment that should require adherence to a moral code.  The most effective way to curb domestic violence rates among professional athletes is by actively prosecuting the cases and requiring a batterer intervention program as part of sentencing.  

Domestic Violence is a crime in every state.  However, the National Coalition Against Violent Athletes asserts that while members of the general population accused of domestic violence are convicted eighty percent of the time, the number is only thirty-eight percent for athletes.  States vary in the methods of prosecuting the crime.  Alaska for example, has a law that requires police to arrest a suspect if there is probable cause that domestic violence has occurred.  This mandatory arrest law has its critics who claim it is a constitutional violation.  Among other arguments, critics say that suspects are being punished before they are convicted of a crime, which violates the suspect’s rights.[7] Today, seven states have mandatory arrest laws for domestic violence.[8] Other criminal justice efforts are “no drop” policies in prosecution offices, which require prosecutors to pursue domestic violence cases even if the victim no longer wishes to.  One of the purposes of these laws is to remove some of the discretionary power of prosecutors to drop domestic violence cases.  This would be particularly useful for prosecution against athletes, who prosecutors may be more willing to drop charges against.  If they are required to pursue the charges, then the suspect gets charged regardless of their popularity or status. 

What are not needed are harsher laws, but rather that the laws in place are actually enforced.  One of the main functions of the criminal system is deterrence.  If athletes knew that they would be prosecuted and punished each time they committed and act of violence, the rates would more than likely decrease.  If they were convicted and sentenced to jail and/or prison time, like other members of the public, the rates would probably decrease.  If this happened, it would also remove some of the cry for league punishment.  Because if a player is in jail or prison, he cannot play in games and would not be paid or be a part of the team for however long he was incarcerated.  By holding athletes responsible for the domestic violence acts they perpetrate, the criminal system can decrease the occurrence.

Another effective method of decreasing domestic violence among athletes is by requiring batterer intervention programs (BIP) as part of the sentence.  A BIP is usually a court-mandated program (but in some cases can be voluntary) that is meant to address an offender’s attitudes towards violence and their victim with the hope of decreasing re-arrest and re-conviction rates.[9] One reason that these programs might be particularly useful for athletes is that many believe athletes are predisposed to commit violence against their partners because of ways they have been trained to think.[10] As part of being an athlete, they are taught that they need to appear aggressive and intimidating to their opponents.  It is hard to shut this off when the individual has to engage in other relationships, so they continue to act aggressively.  If this is true, then it is necessary that the criminal justice system not only punishes them if they commit violent crimes, but also provides therapy in order to prevent re-occurrence.

While there may be some disagreement as to whether athletes actually commit more domestic violence than their counterparts in the general population, there should be no disagreement that they should be prosecuted at the same rate as other members of the population.  Considering the role and the notoriety that professional athletes have in American society and abroad, they should be held to the same standards as the rest of us.  The criminal justice system should not give them a free pass or pretend like this problem does not exist.

Bethany J. Peak
Blogger, Criminal Law Brief


[1] Domestic Violence Facts, National Coalition Against Domestic Violence, available at http://www.ncadv.org/files/DomesticViolenceFactSheet(National).pdf.
[2] Statistics, National Coalition Against Violent Athletes, http://www.ncava.org/Statistics.html.
[4] Justin Peters, No, Seriously, the NFL Really Does Have a Domestic Violence Problem, Slate, Dec. 4, 2012, http://www.slate.com/blogs/crime/2012/12/04/jovan_belcher_murder_suicide_no_seriously_the_nfl_really_does_have_a_domestic.html.
[5] Anna North, The Link Between Athletes And Domestic Violence, Sep. 13, 2011, http://jezebel.com/5839795/the-link-between-athletes-and-domestic-violence.
[6] Jemele Hill, End The Silence About Domestic Violence, ESPN, Dec. 4, 2012, http://espn.go.com/espnw/commentary/8705353/time-end-silence-domestic-violence.
[7] Paul A. Clark, Mandatory Arrest for Misdemeanor Domestic Violence: Is Alaska's Arrest Statute Constitutional?, 27 Alaska L. Rev. 151, 160 (2010).
[8] Thomas L. Hafemeister, If All You Have Is A Hammer: Society's Ineffective Response to Intimate Partner Violence, 60 Cath. U. L. Rev. 919, 1001 (2011) (noting the states are Connecticut, Maine, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oregon, Utah, and Wisconsin)
[9] See Jonathan J. Houston, Batterers’ Intervention Program Analysis, Justice Assistance, Apr. 11, 2011 (noting that in a recent nationwide study only “19.8% of those enrolled in BIPs re-offended – 39.4% of whom re-offended by driving with a suspended driver’s license”).
[10] Bethany P. Withers, The Integrity of the Game: Professional Athletes and Domestic Violence, 1 Harv. J. Sports & Ent. L. 145, 148 (2010).

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Rising Courthouse Violence


When a person considers the safety that they are afforded at a courthouse, they think that it is relatively secure because there are several armed police officers present at all times.  At the same time, it is difficult to ignore that going to a courthouse might be risky business by the mere fact of what occurs in a courthouse on a day-to-day basis.  It does not matter whether the case deals with traffic violations or family-law disputes, many times a judge or jury can have lasting effects on a person’s life.  It is no surprise that emotions run high regardless of what side of the issue you are advocating for.


“There has been a steady increase in courthouse shootings, bombings, and arson attacks over the last 40 years––28 incidents from 1970-79, 45 from 1980-89, 67 from 1990-99 and 88 from 2000-2009.”  Between 1990 and 2007, “there have been at least twenty-six shootings in the courthouses across the United States.”  Out of the twenty-six incidents, around half of the shootings involved family-law disputes.  More recently, between the years of 2010 and 2011, there have been an estimated 117-documented incidents of courthouse violence throughout the United States.                                          

One of the most recent examples of courthouse violence was a shooting that took place on Monday, February 11 at a Delaware courthouse.  “The shooting was a culmination of years of strife between the Matusiewicz and Belford family.”  For several years, David Matusiewicz had been fighting his ex-wife, Christine Belford, for the custody of their three daughters.  During the bitter custody battle, David kidnapped his daughters and took them to Nicaragua after he had forged his ex-wife’s signature on a loan document.  As a result, his parental rights were terminated in 2011 while he was serving a prison sentence for the kidnapping.  Although he lost custody of his daughters, Matusiewicz had a court order against him that required him to make child support payments to his wife––Matusiewicz was behind on the payments.  On the morning of February 11, both Belford and Matusiewicz were present at the courthouse to attend a child-support hearing.  However, Thomas Matusiewicz, David’s father, opened fire in the public lobby of the courthouse killing his former daughter-in-law and her friend by firing a single shot at each woman.  Immediately after, Thomas Matusiewicz exchanged fire with officers and died––although it is uncertain whether it was an officer’s bullet that killed him or a self-inflicted wound.  Two officers wearing armored vests were also injured during this incident.

Courthouse shootings are extremely deadly since the shooter typically shoots his victim from a very close range.  In twenty of the twenty-six incidents that occurred from 1990-2007, there was at least one person who died.  When incidents like this occur, the first questions to arise are:  were there proper safeguards in place?  And, could this incident have been prevented?  After incidents like this, people generally jump to the conclusion that proper safeguards were not in place.  While the details of the Delaware incident are currently under investigation, it is clear that the Delaware courthouse had several safeguards in place.  There are usually a dozen armed officers on duty who are “assisted by roaming court bailiffs and at least one police dog and handler.”  Additionally, there is a security checkpoint near the front door.  However, it is known that Thomas Matusiewicz had not yet passed “through the security perimeter located a few feet inside the front doors.”  If these safeguards were already in place, then what else could be added to protect those people in a courthouse?  The Wilmington Mayor, Dennis P. Williams, thinks that one thing that can be done in order to further safety is “pushing the security out to the entrances, making visitors enter one by one and eliminating the lobby as an area to congregate before being screened.”  This would prevent incidents from occurring inside of the courthouse.  However, others could argue that this would still leave people exposed while they are waiting to go into the courthouse.

Other jurisdictions are taking additional precautions to deter potential perpetrators of violence at courthouses.  For example in Washington state, the Legislature is reviewing whether to pass a bill which would make “misdemeanor assaults that occur in and around courthouses to be treated like felonies, regardless of the victim, and want courthouse felonies to be treated as an aggravating factor for judges to consider during sentencing.”  These stiffer penalties for violent acts in or around a courthouse are not without cause.  Two fairly recent incidents have prompted the attempt to impose stiffer penalties.  The first incident took place in March 2012 where a man stabbed and shot an officer as a courthouse and proceeded to stab a judge who attempted to aid the officer.  The second incident took place in January of this year, when a man assaulted an officer after the officer asked him to the attacker to stop intimidating witnesses.

The idea of pushing security checkpoints to the entrances of courthouses and making stiffer penalties for crimes committed in or around courthouse would work well together to lower the incidents of violence in and around courthouse.  The addition of the stiffer penalties would provide a deterrent effect that might curb some of the incidents.  However, these deterrent effects of these penalties can only go so far since people who are determined to commit a crime will not decide not to hurt someone because they might be in jail for a longer amount of time.  Other additional precautions that could be considered would be screening people prior to them entering the parking lot of the courthouse so as to prevent people carrying weapons and/or hiring more officers to work as security in courthouses.  However, these last two options could be cost prohibitive. 

Elizabeth Rivera
Blogger, Criminal Law Brief

Image courtesy of ABC News

Friday, February 22, 2013

Guilty But Innocent


In November 1992, seventeen year old Daniel Taylor was awaken out of his sleep by police and brought to the police station for questioning.  Almost three and a half hours later Daniel Taylor confessed to a double murder.  The problem here is that Daniel had an alibi, one that was later confirmed by the Assistant State Attorney.  Daniel was locked up in a jail cell on the night of the murders making it impossible for him to have committed this crime.  Yet, he was still tried and convicted.

Wrongful convictions happen and it is the epitome of injustice.  False confessions contribute to approximately twenty-five percent of all wrongful convictions.  Our criminal justice system is built on the notion that you are innocent until proven guilty.  However, once someone falsely confesses the presumption of innocence is taken away and they are not likely to get a fair trial.  There are several factors that contribute to false confessions including but not limited to: (1) contamination of the interrogation, (2) lying about evidence, (3) the length of the interrogation, and (4) using psychological methods on juveniles and cognitively impaired individuals who more impressionable and suggestible. 

The contamination of an interrogationoccurs when law enforcement officials disclose facts of the case during the interrogation.  When the interrogator has disclosed facts of the case to the suspect it makes it hard to determine whether the confession is valid or just a rehash of what the suspect learned during the interrogation.  Additionally, law enforcement officials routinely lie about false evidence to elicit confessions which can be extremely coercive and result in a false confession.  One of the reasons innocent people confess is because they believed that there was overwhelming evidence against them and confessing was the best alternative.  

Lengthy interrogations are another factor that increases the risk of false confessions.  There are several ways that a lengthy interrogation can increase these risks.  First, officers may unintentionally contaminate an interrogation due to exhaustion.  Officers, like suspects, become tired and exhausted after long hours.  Working on a lack of sleep could result in unintentional mistakes.  Furthermore, officers become frustrated when they have been questioning a suspect for several hours to no avail, this could lead to the use of improper and illegal tactics to elicit a confessions.  Additionally, suspects become exhausted making them more suggestible.  Furthermore, when a suspect is exhausted they just want to leave.  Consequently, suspects become more willing to say what the officer wants to hear in order to leave the interrogation room.  Juveniles are even more vulnerable to these factors.

The chances of eliciting a false confession increases when interrogating juveniles.  The court in Roper v. Simmonssaid that children do not have fully matured levels of judgment and are more susceptible to peer-pressure than adults.  Likewise, juveniles would be more susceptible to psychological interrogation techniques used to elicit confessions.  We have many laws in place which limit the rights of juveniles––juveniles are not allowed to vote, smoke cigarettes, or drink alcohol, nor can they get a driver’s license until they are sixteen.  As evident by these laws, we recognize the cognitive limitations of juveniles.  Juveniles are more impressionable and suggestible than adults; therefore they can be more easily coerced and more easily deceived into believing lies about evidence.

In addition to the above mentioned contributing factors, tunnel vision by police and prosecutors can also contribute to false confessions.  Tunnel vision occurs when police and prosecutors focus on one suspect early on in the investigation.  When a false confession occurs, it is hard for police and prosecutors to make sense of an innocent person confessing to a heinous crime that he did not commit.  The investigation stops or changes once a person confesses––law enforcement officials no longer investigate the crime; instead investigating the person with the goal of corroborating what was confessed to.  As a result of tunnel vision, police and prosecutors tend to put more weight to evidence that supports their theory and discount evidence that contradicts their theory.  Tunnel vision infects both the criminal investigation and post-conviction relief for the wrongfully convicted. 

False confessions are extremely difficult to overcome.  A false confession is an admission of guilt which is why false confessions are more likely to lead to wrongful convictions.  In essence, a false confession removes the presumption of innocence that criminal defendants are afforded in this country.  Furthermore, when a suspect confesses to a crime, he simply confirms what the police already believed.  Generally, after a suspect confesses the police and prosecution begin to build a case around that suspect and his confession.  The police and prosecution specifically look for evidence that coincides with what the suspect confessed, making it easy for them to overlook contradicting evidence.  We are logical beings; therefore if a person confesses to a crime with detail and we find evidence that contradicts one of his statements we will tend to believe that the contradicting evidence is wrong. 

Mr. Taylor has spent more than half of his life behind bars for a crime he did not commit.  This injustice should not have happened.  The prosecutor in Mr. Taylor’s case confirmed his alibi before his trial, yet still proceeded with the trial.  “We may never know how many innocent people are in prison.  Instead, we ask how many more will have to be exonerated through the hard science of DNA before every jurisdiction in the country enacts reforms that can prevent this injustice in the first place.”  We cannot control every factor that may contribute to a false confession; however, we can control police and prosecutorial misconduct.  We must be proactive because, as we have illustrated, it is extremely difficult to overcome the weight of a false confession. 

Tonya Davis
Blogger, Criminal Law Brief

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

A Change is Gonna Come: Continuing Reforms in Juvenile Justice Laws


Recently, lawmakers in Georgia have decided a change is needed in their juvenile justice laws.  After Georgia’s legislature passed a series of reforms in March 2012 that revised sentencing laws for non-violent drug and property offenders,[1]lawmakers have turned their attention to fixing Georgia’s increasingly expensive juvenile system.  Will these proposed changes represent a sincere shift in how states adjudicate young offenders, or, will they simply be a temporary stopgap in how Georgia handles the offenses of its youngest offenders and budgetary constraints?

Given, what Georgia lawmakers have considered an overwhelming success from their 2012 criminal justice system reforms––based on both statistics and budgetary freedom––the focus for the current session is how to minimize the financial impact of the juvenile system.[2]  Currently, Georgia has a $300 million budget for the juvenile justice department.  A large percentage of Georgia’s budget––almost two-thirds––goes to youth residential facilities, where the average cost of a bed per year is over $91,000 for long-term facilities and over $88,000 per year for short term youth detention centers.  By comparison, the incarceration of one single adult in a Georgia prison costs approximately $18,000.  Clearly, with such high prices, a recidivism rate of nearly sixty-five percent of youthful offenders incarcerated in residential facilities is nothing less than a systematic failure.[3]

Following the release of the Criminal Justice Reform Council Report on Juvenile Justice,[4]the Chief Justice of the Georgia Supreme Court called for an overhaul of the juvenile justice system.[5]  Chief Justice Carole Hunstein stated that legislators need to divert non-violent juvenile offenders away from residential facilities and create a system in which such offenders become more involved in community programs while taking a look at solutions to other common problems within the juvenile system––substance abuse, domestic relations, and gang involvement.[6]  As the Reform Council Report notes, their recommended changes would save Georgia taxpayers more than $88 million over the next five years.  Two questions remain: (1) what reforms are the legislator proposing, and (2) will it be effective in both serving the needs of offender rehabilitation while minimizing systematic cost?

In their report, the Reform Council proffered a series of fifteen recommendations, which were broken into two categories––(1) those that focused on limiting the use of residential and short term detention facilities to high-risk serious offenders, and (2) those that focused on reducing recidivism by strengthening community supervision programs.  The first category focused on the actual reformation of how the system designates youthful offenders and assesses potential penalties, whereas the second category focused on the need to “cut the fat” from increasingly unsuccessful community supervision programs that have failed to keep offenders from re-entering the justice system.

Chief among the first category’s recommendations is the creation of a two-class system within the Designated Felony Act.  Currently under Georgia law, there is a single all-encompassing felony provision that ranges from burglary to murder.  For the Reform Council, a two-class system that distinguishes the offenders by both severity of offense and risk-level would allow for a better use of state funded resources.  Similarly, the Reform Council recommended the prohibition of low-risk status offenders and misdemeanors offenders from commitment to residential or detention facilities.[7]  The report noted that in 2011, fifty-three percent of juveniles in non-secure residential facilities were adjudicated for either misdemeanors or status offenses.  Following the path of states like Texas, Florida, Virginia, and Alabama, the Reform Council recommended that that status offenders be barred entirely from being sentenced to residential or detention centers; such facilities should be reserved for those juveniles who (1) are adjudicated delinquent for a felony offense; or (2) whose current offense is a misdemeanor but has at least four prior adjudications of delinquency including at least one prior felony adjudication.  Such recommendations, if adopted, should help to curb the inflow of non-violent offenders in an increasingly expensive and inefficient system.  However, what, if any, repercussion can the state offer to those barred from out-of-home facilities (residential or detention placements)?

The second part of the Reform Council’s report addressed the limited sentencing options that juvenile judges have in lieu of out-of-home placement.[8]  However, despite a series of recommendations regarding increased reporting and auditing requirements and the implementation of new juvenile assessment tools––scales that assess the risk and placement of a juvenile––the Reform Council offered few concrete steps for legislators and community officials to follow in reforming alternative programs.  Regardless, these recommendations were drafted into House Bill 242 (“The Juvenile Justice Reform Bill”),[9]which was introduced to the Georgia General Assembly on February 8, 2013. 

It is evident from the high cost of out-of-home placement and the increasing recidivism rates that the current system juvenile justice system in Georgia is broken.  While the steps recommended by the report are a clear start to reassessing the needs of both the individual offenders and the system as a whole, there are still huge concerns with how to reduce recidivism rates.  Keeping low-risk offenders out of residential facilities is certainly a step in the right direction; however, more guidance, reform, and oversight is needed in alternative community based programs. 

Jason Navia
Senior Blog Editor, Criminal Law Brief

 Image by: Ken Lund

[1] http://www.legis.ga.gov/Legislation/20112012/127628.pdf
[2] http://jacksonville.com/news/crime/2013-01-23/story/10000-empty-beds-georgia-county-jails-due-criminal-justice-reforms
[3] Note: The overall recidivism rate of Georgia youth offenders is fifty-three percent.
[4]http://www.georgiacourts.gov/files/Report%20of%20the%20Special%20Council%20on%20Criminal%20Justice%20Reform%20for%20Georgians%202___.pdf
[5] http://www.thecrimereport.org/news/crime-and-justice-news/2013-02-ga-jj-reform
[6] http://www.ajc.com/news/news/crime-law/push-begins-to-reform-juvenile-justice-system/nWJbt/
[7] http://jjie.org/hearings-soon-on-georgia-juvenile-justice-overhaul/104511
[8] http://www.djj.state.ga.us/FacilitiesPrograms/fpRYDCAndYDC.shtml
[9] http://www.legis.ga.gov/Legislation/20132014/130097.pdf