On
February 25, 2014, in an apparent exercise in judicial restraint, the Supreme
Court reaffirmed that a co-occupant’s physical presence is key in
determining whether her objection to a warrantless search of her home overcomes
a co-occupant’s permission in Fernandez v. California. The majority opinion, written by Justice
Alito, narrowed the exception laid out in Georgia v. Randolph, which held a
co-occupant’s present objection
overrides a separate co-occupant’s willingness to consent. In Fernandez, a co-occupant’s objection is
valid only as long as the co-occupant is physically present. In practice, in scenarios involving a
co-occupant willing to grant consent to a warrantless search, the police need
only wait till the objecting co-tenant leaves or remove him from the premises
so long as the removal is justified as a reasonable seizure.
Showing posts with label Fernandez v. California. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fernandez v. California. Show all posts
Friday, March 21, 2014
Sunday, January 19, 2014
Supreme Court Watch
The following are recent Supreme Court cases and opinions relating to criminal law discussed and analyzed. We break down the cases with specific analysis for the affect on practitioners. This page will be updated as opinions are published.

Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
